This Brewer's Challenge was required to include a kid's breakfast cereal. So, given that one parameter, here's what Dustin and Rob came up with:
Dustin - The Captains Nut Butter, Peanut Butter Cap'n Crunch Porter
A porter brewed to resemble eating a bowl of peanut butter cap'n crunch with chocolate milk. Chocolate malts join the cap'n himself in the mash and a touch of lactose in the boil lends a slight sweetness. Served on nitro to accentuate the sweetness of the butter. This porter is best enjoyed in your pajamas.
rob - Cinnamon Toast Crunch Atheist Trappist Style
With over 4 lbs of Cinnamon Toast Crunch added at various times throughout the brewing process, this Trappist style brew has a lot of cinnamon flavor. Couple that spicy cinnamon flavor with the spicy phenolics and fruity esters produced by the yeast and you have a pretty complex beer. Coming in at 8.5% ABV, you'll need your pajamas after a couple.
And the winner is.......by the closest margin in the history of the challenge, 1 vote.....Dustin. Congratulations